Working group
Vol. 5 Núm. 3 (English)
47 min
Cómo citar
Métricas
23
Visualizaciones
Compartir
Compartir
Resumen (EN)
Palabras clave (EN):
Resumen (ES)
Palabras clave (ES):
The care of critically ill pediatric patients is a highly complex clinical challenge in which rapid response, coordination, and evidence-based decision-making are determinants of prognosis. However, healthcare professionals’ exposure to emergency situations has declined markedly in recent decades, partly thanks to advances in prevention and the control of previously common conditions1.
In this context, simulation-based activities (SBAs) have become an essential tool for training healthcare professionals and care teams. These activities enable the practice of technical and non-technical skills (such as communication, leadership, and crisis decision-making) in a safe environment, fostering the development of clinical competencies, increasing professional confidence, and ensuring safe, high-quality care2–4.
The specific characteristics of pediatric emergency medicine (the diversity of conditions and age groups treated, the frequently procedural nature of care, and the high sensitivity of the setting to patient safety risks) make simulation a particularly valuable proactive training strategy in this field1,7. In addition, a wealth of evidence shows that simulation-based activities (SBAs) significantly improve professionals’ technical and non-technical competencies when designed according to sound pedagogical principles5–7. These principles include ensuring psychological safety, providing structured feedback, and defining learning objectives based on an appropriate needs assessment, ideally in the usual clinical setting8,9.
In 2017, the Simulation Working Group of the Spanish Society of Pediatric Emergency Medicine (GTSim-SEUP) was established to foster and promote the standards needed to develop simulation-based activities (SBAs) that facilitate learning in pediatric emergency department (PED) settings. GTSim-SEUP comprises 42 pediatric emergency physicians from centers with varying levels of complexity and from different geographic regions of Spain, with diverse experience and training in clinical simulation.
In 2022, the group conducted a national survey that demonstrated the widespread adoption of simulation in pediatric emergency departments (PEDs) in Spain and identified areas for improvement in professional training and the structure of educational sessions. Based on these findings and in keeping with the principles of the Choosing Wisely movement10–11, in 2023 the GTSim-SEUP initiated the development of a set of “do not do” recommendations (DNDRs) aimed at preventing recurring errors in the design and implementation of simulation-based activities in pediatric emergency care.
The aim of this study is to present the DNDRs in clinical simulation in pediatric emergency medicine, resulting from an expert consensus process using a modified Delphi methodology.
An expert consensus study was conducted using a modified Delphi methodology, widely recognized for developing recommendations and clinical practice guidelines12. The methodological process was based on the procedures used to develop “do not do” lists within the Spanish Society of Pediatric Emergency Medicine (SEUP) and on similar projects in other pediatric fields13–15.
The initiative originated during the 27th Annual Meeting of SEUP (2023), where GTSim-SEUP undertook to develop a set of DNDRs applicable to the design and implementation of SBA in our setting.
The development process was structured into three main phases:
Phase 1: Generation of proposals (November 2023 – January 2024): A coordinating group of four experts with extensive experience in training through pediatric clinical simulation was established. Using a brainstorming session, this panel developed a preliminary list of potential recommendations on practices to avoid when preparing or conducting SBA in pediatric emergency medicine. The proposals were based on the experts’ professional experience, documents issued by scientific societies, and the evidence available in the literature.
Phase 2: Evaluation and consensus (January – November 2024): All GTSim-SEUP members were invited to evaluate each proposal using a 9-point Likert scale (1 = complete disagreement; 9 = complete agreement). Recommendations were considered accepted if they received a mean score ≥ 8 and at least two-thirds of participants rated them ≥ 7. Proposals with a mean score < 6 were discarded, while those with mean scores between 6 and 8 were submitted to a second voting round, applying the same consensus criteria for their acceptance or definitive exclusion.
Phase 3: Review and final drafting (December 2024): The coordinating group compiled the selected recommendations and reviewed their wording to ensure consistency, avoid redundancies, and maintain a uniform format. The final versions were subsequently validated by unanimous consensus of the group, forming the definitive document of DNDRs in SBA in pediatric emergency medicine.
During the proposal generation phase (Phase 1), 20 DNDRs suggested by the expert coordinating group were collected. After applying the consensus process using a modified Delphi methodology, eight DNDRs made up the final list of recommendations (Figure 1).
Subsequently, the coordinating group reviewed and harmonized the wording to ensure conceptual coherence and avoid potential overlap. No recommendations had to be discarded as redundant. The eight final DNDRs and their summarized rationale are presented in Table 1. The recommendations were distributed across the following thematic domains: Learning environment and culture (n = 2), Design and planning (n = 3), Team and context (n = 1), and Debriefing (n = 2).
| No. | Statement of the DNDR | Domain | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Make participants feel judged, ignoring their intention to learn. | Environment and culture | Perceiving judgment increases anxiety and reduces participation. In contrast, “good judgment” debriefing promotes psychological safety and participants’ reflective learning |
| 2 | Conduct SBA without establishing a safe environment that fosters curiosity and respect. | Environment and culture | A clear prebriefing on objectives, roles, and rules reduces participant stress and encourages active participation by creating an atmosphere of trust and respect. |
| 3 | Design SBA without considering participants’ needs and competencies. | Design and planning | Needs assessment aligns simulation objectives with actual training gaps. This increases the activity’s clinical relevance and improves learning and retention. |
| 4 | Consider simulation only for clinical skills, omitting non-technical skills (e.g., communication, leadership). | Design and planning | Non-technical skills are proven determinants of patient safety. Integrating them into simulation objectives and assessment increases training effectiveness. |
| 5 | Design scenarios without adjusting their complexity to participants’ level. | Design and planning | Gradually increasing difficulty allows for better learning progression and prevents cognitive overload, optimizing skill acquisition |
| 6 | Conduct SBA without including diverse professional profiles when feasible. | Team and context | Interdisciplinary participation replicates the real emergency department work environment, improving team coordination and competencies |
| 7 | Run scenarios without a structured subsequent debriefing. | Debriefing | Debriefing guides critical reflection on performance, identifies knowledge gaps, and consolidates learning for transfer to practice. Omitting it drastically limits the educational impact of simulation. |
| 8 | Conduct debriefing as one-way feedback (without facilitating a learning conversation). | Debriefing | Debriefing requires intentional facilitation (active listening, inquiry, and structure). If conducted as simple one-way criticism, its educational value and participants’ reflection are diminished. |
DNDRs: recommendations of practices to avoid; SBA: simulation-based activities
Finally, the eight DNDRs were grouped and presented in the document “Recommendations on what NOT TO DO in simulation activities in Pediatric Emergency Medicine,” which was endorsed by SEUP and is available on the society’s website16.
The final document offers a comprehensive framework encompassing all phases of the simulation process, from creating a safe learning environment to rigorous scenario planning and conducting a structured debriefing, applicable to the development of both technical and non-technical skills.
These recommendations reflect the essential elements that determine the quality and safety of SBA in pediatric emergency departments, underscoring the need for a systematic and structured approach to simulation-based education.
Psychological safety is an essential prerequisite for effective learning in simulation17,18. Several studies have shown that merely perceiving judgment or criticism limits learners’ active participation and reduces knowledge retention, whereas an environment of respect and openness fosters reflection and participants’ self-confidence17,19. In this regard, adopting debriefing models based on good judgment or advocacy-inquiry techniques makes it possible to address errors made during simulation constructively, turning them into educational opportunities to improve performance20,21.
Regarding scenario design and planning, the consensus reached reinforces the importance of tailoring activities to participants’ learning needs and competency levels. Prior needs assessment and the progressive dosing of complexity are recognized strategies for improving learning transfer and learners’ intrinsic motivation 6,8. Furthermore, incorporating interprofessional teams into simulations is consistent with evidence supporting collaborative training as a means of strengthening communication and coordination in critical situations 22,23.
Furthermore, structured debriefing is established as the core of learning in simulation. Beyond its formal implementation, it should be understood as a facilitated conversation that stimulates critical reflection, performance analysis, and the consolidation of experience for application in clinical practice 24. A certain structure is generally considered necessary for debriefing: it should include a reactions phase immediately after the scenario to facilitate emotional expression, followed by a phase focused on understanding the events that occurred during the scenario, and a third phase involving analysis and generalization. A summary and a proposal for improvement after the scenario facilitate the transfer of knowledge and skills to the real work environment 25. The absence of an appropriate structure or the use of unsuitable techniques can significantly reduce the educational impact of simulation-based activities 26.
Likewise, simulation should be conceived as a comprehensive tool that encompasses both clinical and nontechnical skills, competencies widely recognized as determinants of patient safety 27. Limiting simulation exclusively to technical training diminishes its potential as an educational strategy and reduces its contribution to the development of resilient and effective clinical teams.
This study provides a consensus framework that may serve as a reference for standardizing and continuously improving simulation activities in pediatric emergency medicine. One limitation is that the findings derive from an expert consensus process rather than a direct empirical evaluation of the impact of the proposed recommendations. Future studies should explore the implementation of these recommendations in practice, as well as their effects on educational and clinical outcomes, in order to validate and strengthen their applicability in real-world clinical settings.
The application of the modified Delphi methodology made it possible to reach consensus on eight actions to avoid in pediatric emergency simulation. These recommendations highlight that the effectiveness of simulation depends on its alignment with training needs, participants’ level of competence, integration of interprofessional learning, and balance between technical and non-technical skills. The absence of these elements may compromise both the educational experience and its impact on clinical practice.
Implementing the proposed recommendations may help standardize and improve the quality of simulation activities in pediatric emergency departments, strengthening the preparedness of multidisciplinary teams and promoting patient safety through ongoing training, periodic evaluation, and rigorous scenario design 28,29.
The authors wish to thank all members of GTSim-SEUP for their active participation in the consensus rounds and their contributions to the development of the recommendations.
No funding was received for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
I declare that there are no commercial or financial conflicts of interest related to this research.
Xoan González Rioja: conceptualization, formal analysis, data collection, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing. Anna Pizà Oliveras, Anna Orejuela Ribera, Vanesa Arias Constanti, and David Muñoz Santanach: conceptualization, writing – original draft, writing – review and editing.
Gemini 2.5 and ChatGPT 5 to improve readability during the writing process.
The data supporting the findings of this study are available upon request from the corresponding author.
Explorar
Artículos
Volúmenes
Sobre la revista
Más leídos
Emergencias Pediátricas
Emergencias Pediátricas
Emergencias Pediátricas
Emergencias Pediátricas
Emergencias Pediátricas